Defining quality
Given how much we talk about it, it's surprising that there's a lot of confusion about what quality is.
What's a higher quality car: a one-year old Honda Civic or a brand new top of the line Bentley?
It turns out that there are at least two useful ways to describe quality, and the conflict between them leads to the confusion...
Quality of design: Thoughtfulness and processes that lead to user delight, that make it likely that someone will seek out a product, pay extra for it or tell a friend.
Quality of manufacture: Removing any variation in tolerances that a user will notice or care about.
In the case of the Civic, the quality of manufacture is clearly higher by any measure. The manufacturing is more exact, the likelihood that the car will perform (or not perform) in a way you don't expect is tiny.
On the other hand, we can probably agree that the design of the Bentley is more bespoke, luxurious and worthy of comment.
Let's think about manufacturing variation for a second: Fedex promises overnight delivery. 10:20 vs 10:15 is not something the recipient cares about. Tomorrow vs. Thursday, they care about a lot. The goal of the manufacturing process isn't to reach the perfection of infinity. It's to drive tolerances so hard that the consumer doesn't care about the variation. Spending an extra million dollars to get five minutes faster isn't as important to the Fedex brand as spending a million dollars to make the website delightful.
Dropbox is a company that got both right. The design of the service is so useful it now seems obvious. At the same time, though, and most critically, the manufacture of the service is to a very high tolerance. Great design in a backup service would be useless if one in a thousand files were corrupted.
Microsoft struggles (when they struggle) because sometimes they get both wrong. Software that has a user interface that's a pain to use rarely leads to delight, and bugs represent significant manufacturing defects, because sometimes (usually just before a presentation), the software doesn't work as expected--a noticed variation.
The Shake Shack, many New York burger fans would argue, is a higher quality fast food experience than McDonald's, as evidenced by lines out the door and higher prices. Except from a production point of view. The factory that is McDonald's far outperforms the small chain in terms of efficient production of the designed goods within certain tolerances. It's faster and more reliable. And yet, many people choose to pay extra to eat at Shake Shack. Because it's "better." Faster doesn't matter as much to the Shake Shack customer.
The balance, then, is to understand that marketers want both. A short-sighted CFO might want neither.
Deming defined quality as: (result of work effort)/(total costs). Unless you understand both parts of that fraction, you'll have a hard time allocating your resources.
Consider what Phillip Crosby realized a generation ago: Quality is free.
It's cheaper to design marketing quality into the product than it is to advertise the product.
It's cheaper to design manufacturing quality into a factory than it is to inspect it in after the product has already been built.
These go hand in hand. Don't tell me about server uptime if your interface is lame or the attitude of the people answering the phone is obnoxious. Don't promise me a brilliant new service if you're unable to show up for the meeting. Don't show me a boring manuscript with no typos in it, and don't try to sell me a brilliant book so filled with errors that I'm too distracted to finish it.
There are two reasons that quality of manufacture is diminishing in importance as a competitive tool:
a. incremental advances in this sort of quality get increasingly more expensive. Going from one defect in a thousand to one in a million is relatively cheap. Going from one in a million to one in a billion, though, costs a fortune.
b. As manufacturing skills increase (and information about them is exchanged) it means that your competition has as much ability to manufacture with quality as you do.
On the other hand, quality of design remains a fast-moving, judgment-based process where supremacy is hard to reach and harder to maintain.
And yet organizations often focus obsessively on manufacturing quality. Easier to describe, easier to measure, easier to take on as a group. It's essential, it's just not as important as it used to be.




by Karl Greenberg
by Karl Greenberg
by Tanya Irwin 
by Karl Greenberg
by Karlene Lukovitz
by Karl Greenberg
Now that football fans officially have an NFL season to watch, ESPN takes celebrating a touchdowns to a whole new level with the "Evolution of the Touchdown Dance." Anyone with a computer and a friend who forwards funny videos is all too familiar with Judson Laipply's "
Stride gum not only has flavor that lasts a ridiculously long time, it has feelings, too. An empty classroom sets the scene for a scared and lonely voice, hoping that "Johnny" returns. The voice comes from underneath Johnny's desk, and it's his piece of Stride gum that's been left behind, feeling abandoned as it remembers incidents of the past.
If "Earth's Treasure," in the eyes of aliens, is $1 fountain drinks from McDonald's, then we've either got problems -- or we've hit the jackpot. A soda fountain dispenser is brought onboard an alien spaceship and described as something cherished by billions. The top alien goes straight for the Dr Pepper -- I would, too -- and sheds a layer of face to reveal a large smile. Too bad a man on his lunch break will remain parched, thanks to the missing soda dispenser. What will he wash his double cheeseburger down with?
Jell-O Pudding launched a 3D billboard in New York City that monitors the world's mood on Twitter. The billboard,
Pretzel M&M'S pick the lesser of two evils in "Hungry Eyes." Salty pretzel and sweet M&M are faced with being eaten by an attractive woman or a man with a questionable combover and creepy look in his eyes. The awesome and underused song "Hungry Eyes" plays while the man gawks at the duo.
Mitchum launched the latest TV ad for its "Love Thy Pits" campaign, showing a mom who's cool under pressure. She might be panicked on the outside, but her pits stay calm and dry. It's not every day that you pick up your son from soccer practice, drive off and then realize you have the wrong kid in your back seat, is it? "Dawson's Kid" goes home to his family and the woman's actual son is "triple seat-belted in the back seat of the less-than-pimped minivan."
Professor Nathaniel Burke of Farmer's Insurance, played by J.K. Simmons, hires a "Cat Burglar" for his students to observe in the hopes they in turn can help their consumers protect themselves. The burglar is strapped to a dolly, reminiscent of Hannibal Lecter in "Silence of the Lambs," but sans face mask. One student is skeptical about the burglar's talents until he turns around to find a home's contents askew on the lawn... and his own watch missing.
Michelin's fourth ad in its global campaign "The Right Tire Changes Everything" illustrates that rain can be a more-dangerous foe, especially when your tires are sub-par. A rainstorm wreaks havoc for a father and son as they maneuver slippery roads, avoiding a near-miss with another car. When it comes time to brake suddenly to avoid a fallen tree branch, the Michelin man comes to the rescue, swapping tires on the man's car and enabling him to stop before hitting the branch. The ad promotes the Primacy MXM4 tire, which touts a braking distance of up to 29 feet shorter in wet conditions.
Random iPad app of the week: LazyTown Entertainment, creator of the now-defunct "LazyTown" children's TV show, along with Castle Builders, launched the LazyTown BooClips iPad app. BooClips helps kids to read by using sign language interpretation, translation to different languages and an animated magnifying glass. The digital book features music and songs from the "LazyTown" TV series and allows kids or parents to narrate a story using the app's voiceover function. The app is free in the
by Tanya Irwin
by Karl Greenberg
by Karl Greenberg 
by Karl Greenberg
by Karlene Lukovitz
by Karl Greenberg 






